[a] Mid-Mountain Passage RL
The midterm assignment in all of my classes is pivotal in several senses of the term. Of course, the first thing students realize is that it is important—pivotal. A solid chunk of the grade turns (pivots) on it. The next sense is even more significant, though. The midterm assignment is designed to encourage students to consider all of the work they have done in the first half of the course and to put it together in a midterm assignment that helps them to pivot to the second half of the course. For our course, the "historical thinking" readings that we did for Week 9 are pivotal for this assignment. Read and reread them carefully, and then bring that knowledge to the assignment.
HIST 150 (ENVS 295)
Mountains
Midterm Assignment—Thinking Historically
The Basics
Read the "historical thinking" essays from Week 9 and then pick any historical topic. As we have discussed in class, these can range from a famous historical battle, a presidential election (in the past), a sports figure (or team), or anything else that is historical. Hint: Everything that has happened, even a minute ago, is historical.
Preparation
Now that you have your topic (let's use the classroom example of the 1956 US presidential election between Dwight Eisenhower and Adlai Stevenson), review the historical thinking issues that we have talked about over-and-over in class the last few weeks.
R.G. Collingwood
"If you can memorize it, it is not history"
Use Collingwood's overarching idea as the "umbrella" concept, and explain, in several paragraphs (about a page) your topic and why just memorizing, like a bad high school history course, is not sufficient to understanding it.
Now that you have drafted that page (or so), analyze the following six ways of thinking about historical time and historical analysis.
Fernand Braudel
Historical time as a "long duration"
Historical time as a series of structures
Historical time as the ebb-and-flow of events
Paul Cohen
History as narrative and analysis
History as the experience of people (who don't know what happens next)
History as mythology (we take "facts" and expand them...for some)
It is o.k., after you have drafted the overview of your topic (through Collingwood), to write a kind of "memo," in which you take each of the six items above and write a long-ish paragraph or so (think of the exam you took a few weeks ago). It is just as acceptable to write and essay that connects your overview with the six items. The form is up to you, but you need to analyze those six ways of thinking about historical time (Braudel) and historical writing (Cohen).
I will make clear here, in case it hasn't been obvious in class, that nothing is more important than Cohen on experience and mythology. We will continue to discuss these issues in class, and especially on Thursday, November 7 (our last class before the paper is due).
Reminders
1. This assignment is meant to tie together your perspectives on historical thinking (it is much more than the things you can memorize, even if that is all that most K-12 education tests).
2. Don’t forget that I will be evaluating this assignment with the assumption that you are trying to explain these matters to “intelligent non-specialists.” That means that I do not want you to “skip” those portions that you know I know. I want you to explain them. I want you to be the expert who is explaining these matters to someone who does not know much about history, and probably thinks about it only in terms of memorizing things.
3. Follow standard Chicago Manual of Style citation form, and use my writing guide as you proceed. This is a “formal” review essay, and the second section of the guide (grammar and style) guidelines should be followed closely.
4. There should be a short bibliography of sources (class books and any outside materials that you have consulted) at the end of your document.
5. Good luck. There is more than enough material to write any number of essays. Choose several good points, scenes, or themes. Then write an essay. Please revise it before turning it in, and pay close attention to the grammatical points I mentioned in your letter.
6. Put in an illustration. By now, you should know why.
Due by 5:00 p.m. on Sunday, November 10 at 5:00 p.m. (hard copy in MI 206).
Use the word count feature of your software and put the word total at the bottom of the essay, e.g. “2,862 words."